Reverse Seared Beef Tenderloin Steak

Reverse Seared Beef Tenderloin Steak

Served with Porcini Mushroom Sauce

If your beef tenderloin doesn't feel upscale enough as is, drizzling on a deep, velvety mushroom sauce will definitely do the trick.

Complexity icon

Complexity

More Involved

Prep Time icon

Prep Time

0 H 40 M

Appliance icon

Appliance

Oven

Cook Time icon

Cook Time

0 H 40 M

Master Class: Your Pocket-Sized Cookbook

Let’s Cook

Ingredients:

  • Beef Tenderloin Steak

    About 5 cm / 2 thick recommended Should be thawed to fridge temperature before starting cook

  • Oil

    Just enough to lightly coat the pan Oils with higher smoke point recommended, like avocado or grapeseed oil

  • Salt to Taste

    Salt flakes recommended

  • Black Pepper to Taste

    Freshly ground recommended

  • Tools:

  • 125g / ½ Cup Dried Porcini Mushrooms

    Can be fresh if available May be located in different aisles in each store

  • 125ml / ½ Cup Red Wine

    Dry wine recommended

  • ½ Shallot

  • 250ml / 1 Cup Heavy Cream

  • 250ml / 1 Cup Beef Stock

    Low-sodium or no-salt stock recommended Low-sodium vegetable stock can be substituted

  • 2 Tbsp Oil

    Oils with higher smoke point recommended, like avocado or grapeseed oil

  • Salt to Taste

    Salt flakes recommended

  • Black Pepper to Taste

  • About This Recipe:

    This is the perfect recipe for those times when you feel like a classic salt-and-pepper cut of beef tenderloin just isn't fancy enough. Of course we're kidding, no one has ever thought that. But still, if you're feeling ambitious on a special occasion and really want to knock your steak into the stratosphere, you need a sauce that's worthy of such a high-end cut of beef. Porcini mushrooms are considered a luxury ingredient, not just because they're tricky to find and cultivate, but also because of their deep and autumnal flavor that makes them so unique. Cooking them up in this creamy blend will give you a truly magical mushroom sauce to elevate your tenderloin. No, not that kind of magic mushroom sauce. It just tastes crazy good. A cut of beef this classy deserves side dishes that are just as sophisticated. Sautéed vegetables will add color to your plate, and you can do your own elevated take on beef and potatoes with a garlic and herb mash or some cheesy scalloped potatoes. You won't want a wine that might overpower the more subtle flavor of the beef, so milder reds like pinot noir are a good idea.

    Cooking Method:

  • 1

    Soak Mushrooms

    Soak your mushrooms in your wine for 10m.

    Fresh porcini mushrooms can be hard to hunt down, need really specific growing conditions, and have to be carefully cultivated. As you can imagine, all of this adds up to a hefty price tag. To save our wallets some pain, we chose to use dried mushrooms for this recipe. Soaking them in wine gives them some extra flavor, and it also adds moisture to the mushrooms to revive them and make them easier to chop.

  • 2

    Mince Shallot

    Finely chop your shallot.

    Shallots are popular in sauces because their flavor is milder and more refined than some other onions. While they're cooking, they also release a subtle sweetness.

  • 3

    Chop Mushrooms

    Squeeze the extra wine from your mushrooms, then roughly chop them up. Set the wine aside.

  • 4

    Pre-Heat Oven

    Pre-heat your oven to 250°F (120°C). This can take up to 15m.

    We know, waiting for your food to cook isn't always fun. But as much as you may want to just throw your steak in a blacksmithing forge so it can be done in 30s, the best way to bring out this cut's characteristic tenderness is by cooking low and slow.

  • 5

    Season Steak

    Sprinkle salt and pepper all over and pat it in.

  • Step-By-Step Videos

    1
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10
    11
    12
    13
    14
    15
    16
    17
    18
    19
    20
    21
    22
    23
    24
    25
    26

    Soak Mushrooms

    Soak your mushrooms in your wine for 10m.

    MEATER APP

    A friendly app designed for you

    Effortlessly navigate our user friendly app. We keep it easy peasy over here.

    Available on the App store 4.7 star rating
    Available on the Play store 4.4 star rating

    Cook Estimator

    Get a cook countdown. What will you do with 1 hour 26 minutes? Craft a beverage? Deep dive into cryptocurrency? Rewatch The Office?

    MEATER Master Class™

    Easy-to-follow recipes that inspire on your foodventures.

    1. Select

    Choose from a library of dishes curated by our in-house chef.

    2. Prep

    Head to the pantry (or store) and grab all the ingredients on the checklist.

    3. Cook

    Follow the directions, cook, and enjoy! We hope you're wearing your stretchy pants.

    Cook Graphs

    Like nerding out? So do we. And this is way more fun than calculus.